Regulatory and political in uence on accounting
However, in Germany, accounting is also influenced by decisions of the tax courts and by tax measurement rules. Ever since possessors of wealth appointed other people to manage their money, the agents have been reporting back on what they did with it in the form of the stewardship report.
Not least of these is war.
Standard setting at the iasc b is and has long been permeated by politics
Sign up to our newsletter or view a sample. If you consult a history of financial reporting in Europe, such as Walton , you can find plenty of evidence of this model in operation. The link between taxation and financial reporting is stronger in some countries than others, and is typically much more pronounced in the accounting of owner-managed business than multinational groups. If you are new to university study, you may be interested in our Access Courses or Certificates. Not all regulators have an overt set of objectives like this, and even when they do, there are usually other factors that come into play. The legislator believes that this is good for the health of the economy, and that users of financial statements are getting good information, precisely because it does not reflect the economic state of the company — they are protected by undervaluation. This issue of different countries perceiving financial reporting as having different objectives is one of the important cultural variables that affect financial reporting. In this next section, cultural issues can be seen to have a considerable impact on the methods used in each country to regulate its accounting, and indeed on whether regulation is perceived to be necessary. The exploratory research in this thesis analyses the influence of culture and politics on accounting change since independence.
Consequently, court decisions jurisprudence build up alongside professional experience to create generally accepted accounting principles, but the technical detail comes from the practitioner, not the statute.
We probably take it for granted that financial reporting is regulated in various ways, but it is not necessarily obvious that it should be regulated, and, if it is regulated, it is not self-evident who should do the regulation. The Swiss Commercial Code code des obligations in the s addressed its rules to the financial statements of individual companies.
The standard setting process is a political process discuss
Burchell, Clubb and Hopwood analysed a particular case of accounting change in the UK. So the issue when you look at a particular jurisdiction is how they interpret these objectives and which seem to get the most emphasis. Consequently they went into liquidation, often, as is the case with small business networks, taking other businesses down with them. All standard-setters wish the economy to be enhanced not damaged by their rules, all want those entitled to information about the company to have good quality information, all want the application of the rules not to be too onerous, all want the information to be comparable and consistent, none can ignore that accounting rules will influence tax rules in any jurisdiction, and so on. Ever since possessors of wealth appointed other people to manage their money, the agents have been reporting back on what they did with it in the form of the stewardship report. The counter-argument is that this leaves inefficiencies in the market, because it takes a little while for the poor quality information to be clearly identified, and there will always be those who believe they can deceive the market e. This would require a major change in attitudes to regulations and how they are formulated and enforced. This OpenLearn course provides a sample of postgraduate study in Business Learning outcomes After studying this course, you should be able to: identify factors that have influenced the development of financial reporting provide examples of how those factors have effected change in particular countries list a number of variables that affect the development of accounting rules in different jurisdictions explain the contingent model of accounting change apply the theories of accounting development to new situations. There was only one line on groups of companies, saying that they should prepare consolidated accounts.
This new business unit ushered in the rise of the professional manager, hired for expertise in a particular activity, and relegated the owner-manager to the small business.
This in turn produced a new sophistication in the stewardship function — there was a separation between manager and investor, and financial reporting had to evolve to meet the needs of communicating information between the two. In some cultures, annual financial statements are perceived to be mostly about taxation, not reporting economic performance.
Enron was perceived to have been allowed to get away with fraudulent financial statements because the auditor was weak and internal quality control in the firm was not good enough.
This issue of different countries perceiving financial reporting as having different objectives is one of the important cultural variables that affect financial reporting.
Find out more about all our free courses. After all, if a litre of petrol is the same in Wales, Spain and Australia, why are company profits not measured with the same uniformity?
In the markets, the multinational is presenting its account of past management action as an incitement to investors to continue to invest. Of course, they do not create something that does not exist although some companies do try to use the rules that way!
Politics in accounting standard setting
In some cultures, annual financial statements are perceived to be mostly about taxation, not reporting economic performance. The standard-setters believe that the economy is protected by transparent information, so that the investor can make economic judgments. Sign up to our newsletter or view a sample. A US financial reporting scandal had the unintended consequence of opening up US supervision of audit all over the world. If you are new to university study, you may be interested in our Access Courses or Certificates. So the issue when you look at a particular jurisdiction is how they interpret these objectives and which seem to get the most emphasis. Burchell, Clubb and Hopwood analysed a particular case of accounting change in the UK. This analyses how, in a particular economic context, various interests concerned with financial reporting arrived at a consensus that an additional financial statement, a statement of value added, should be part of the company reporting package. When looking at the standards of the International Accounting Standards Committee IASC and its successor the IASB, put together over a continuous period of no more than 30 years, it is evident that these different approaches, different priorities, etc. One of the reasons that some European countries find it difficult to accept IFRS is that they are used to an environment where the rule changes occur once every 20 years, not one like the US, where several rules are changed each year. Traditionally, the Swiss rules have been almost exclusively concerned about taxation and a stable economy. The process of accounting change is seen to be political with government involvement in accounting, accounting regulations promulgated through the parliamentary system and accounting change being the outcome of interactions, both formal and informal, between the main parties interested in accounting, identified to be government regulatory institutions, professional accounting institutes, the corporate sector and parliament.
based on 85 review